Mud Lake = Pan fish (all of the types), cat fish, giant goldfish
It's private, and who knows what kind of chemicals have been dumped in it? I would say eating perch or crappie out of there is risky at best.
Fun place to watch hawks diving after fish. The fish are so plentiful in there, you can pull them in one after another using just a bare hook presentation. It has a good turtle population as well. Nice sunsets there too.
The property on the lake is for sale for $1M+.
Yes you are right on the types of fish. I didn't see any gold fish though. I found the lake peaceful. I was the only person there (Friday afternoon). I caught mostly pan fish and almost what appeared to be a trout. I used only worms. I think it makes it easier. For me anyway. And i'm not a chick that gets grossed out by hooking a worm