fishing at Toronto Islands for Pike on May 6, 2008

Ontario Fishing Forums

Help Support Ontario Fishing Forums:

chibi

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2008
Messages
249
Fishing:
On Tuesday, May 6th, frozenfire, his friend, and I ventured to the Toronto Islands for pike. We skipped the opening weekend due to bad weather. We headed down at about 9:30 to 10:00am and arrived on the island at about 11am. We got off at Hanlan’s point and went along the route to Center Island. We all thought that the weather would’ve been more kind to us, but we were wrong. We were confronted with chilly overcast skies and on/off showers.

As we were casting along one of the breakwalls of one of the canals, I had a hit and grew excited. Unfortunately, it came off after about 1 second. With disappointment, I reeled in the lure to see that the leader was all mangled up. I turned to frozenfire and he said that the pike had overshot the lure, and grabbed the leader instead of the lure. He told me to quickly cast it back in the same direction. At first I thought there was no way it was going to hit again, but I listened to him anyway. What do you know, frozenfire was right. I wasn’t even paying attention as I was reeling it back in and focusing on the passing boat, but frozenfire saw the pike come back up and inhale the lure! It was a short fight with the fish being quickly landed. It measured in at 33 inches and 7 lbs 5 oz.

We kept casting as we headed towards Center Island. frozenfire had a big fish on which gave quite a fight! It turned out to be a huge Toronto island carp! It was foul hooked on its dorsal fin. He brought the fish in to remove the lure and we decided to take a quick picture too, just for you guys!

As we reached the Center Island bridge, frozenfire decided to change things up and use a jointed rapala instead of an xrap. Instantly he gets one on and it measured to be 23 inches. Small fry if you ask me j/k.

We then fished the Center Island area for a little longer and called it a day, leaving by 6pm. The fish did not cooperate today. Only 2 pike landed and 1 follow (it chased down frozenfire’s white ghost xrap, but turned away last second).

We bumped into some other fishermen towards the end who had similar results as us. They mentioned that there were a whole bunch of police boats cruising around the islands checking for fishing licenses. It's good to know action is being taken against those who are breaking the law.

Equipment:
6’6” M Shimano compre spinning rod with 2500 Stradic spooled with 30lbs PowerPro, stainless steel leader, with assorted xraps and a lucky craft lure (mine)

openfire - the lucky craft lure didn't produce today! Hopefully next trip =).

6’6” M Shimano compre casting rod with Curado 200 DPV equipped with 12lbs mono, stainless steel leader, with assorted jerk baits (frozenfire and his friend, who have the same rod and set up)

Pictures:
overcast, grey, day
image.php


my pike
image.php


where the pike was caught
image.php


to the right
image.php


frozenfire's carp!
image.php


frozenfire's pike
image.php


where frozenfire caught his pike
image.php


to the right
image.php


behind us
image.php


Directions:
Find your way to downtown Toronto and take the ferry to Toronto Islands. Regardless of which stop you get off, there will be place after place to try! Start casting till your arm falls off d=. Wear comfortable shoes!

Map of where the pike were landed:
image.php
 
Excellent.

Next time can you take a picture of the sky? straight up too? That way I can pin point the location. LOL j/k.

So anyways... how did you guys worked the lures? That is what I want to know more than anything else.

Also, what time did you guys left the island?
Because...

I was there today aswell....!!

I arrived around 1430hour and fished until 1800hour and laid down on a bench until the 1840hour 'ish ferry back @ centre. I guess you guys took the boat before? as there was only 5 people that got on.

By the way, no report from me as I totally got SKUNKED! I started working the Centre area with crown xrap and had seen few large pike follow but no taker. From here I worked towards the Ward where I've seen several fairly good size pike just suspending close to shoreline. Toss Xrap, Husky Jerk with fast and slow retrieve and it just wouldn't bother with the lure.
I gotta say... water level sure is higher than this time last year and definitely less weeds than last year this time too.
Maybe in few more days it'll get better. Than again by that time... bigger fish would move out?

Oh yeah... Toronto Island carp sure is huge!

Btw... i haven't seen any police or co today and only seen one other fisherman going home when I arrived. He had a small telescope rod with some spinner.


Btw... frozenfire how are you liking your new reel? I guess you prefer right crank. I like lefty.
 
MikeyMikey said:
Excellent.
So anyways... how did you guys worked the lures? That is what I want to know more than anything else.

not sure about frozenfire and his friend but all i did was reel it slowly, so it looked like the xrap was a fish casually swimming about.

MikeyMikey said:
Also, what time did you guys left the island?
Because...

I was there today aswell....!!

I arrived around 1430hour and fished until 1800hour and laid down on a bench until the 1840hour 'ish ferry back @ centre. I guess you guys took the boat before? as there was only 5 people that got on.

we JUST missed each other! we took the ferry at 6pm at Centre Island. we were thinking of staying later but needed to pick up a friend from work. at this time there were many on the ferry... i would say at least 30.

MikeyMikey said:
By the way, no report from me as I totally got SKUNKED! I started working the Centre area with crown xrap and had seen few large pike follow but no taker. From here I worked towards the Ward where I've seen several fairly good size pike just suspending close to shoreline. Toss Xrap, Husky Jerk with fast and slow retrieve and it just wouldn't bother with the lure.
I gotta say... water level sure is higher than this time last year and definitely less weeds than last year this time too.
Maybe in few more days it'll get better. Than again by that time... bigger fish would move out?

better luck next time!!! frozenfire's friend got skunked too but he was happy to be out fishing.
you know we thought there might be some consistency in colour choices to attract them... but there wasn't! usually they go bananas for the silver colour xrap... even with its popularity among fishers
i'm not sure about the bigger fish moving out... frozenfire will know though.

MikeyMikey said:
Oh yeah... Toronto Island carp sure is huge!

i'm still thinking his carp was one of the medium sized carp of the islands... they get soooooooooooooo big. they are cute in a way too haha.

mikeymikey, are you going back to the islands anytime soon? we're probably gonna go thursday again... i start working next week so we're trying to fit in as much fishing as possible right now...
 
Awesome report chibi
great pike & carp caught.by the way what time tomorrow are you guys going tomorrow.I may join you guys.

Also that pike u caught was it released.Do you know if big pike like u caught are good to eat.let me know.thx
 
i will probably visit the islands on monday. gonna go early this time as i prefer later morning to mid aft.

and yes... there are even biggER carps there.
 
idesign said:
Awesome report chibi
great pike & carp caught.by the way what time tomorrow are you guys going tomorrow.I may join you guys.

Also that pike u caught was it released.Do you know if big pike like u caught are good to eat.let me know.thx

hey, thanks

i have no idea what time we'll be there. i'm going to a career fair and i don't know how long i'll be there. also we might not head over if it rains. if you see us, say hi!

we released all the fish. i don't know how pike tastes to be honest but the fish from these waters are not healthy to consume. if you catch anything, i suggest letting it go after taking a picture!
 
MikeyMikey said:
i will probably visit the islands on monday. gonna go early this time as i prefer later morning to mid aft.

and yes... there are even biggER carps there.

that's probably the best time to go. last year they hit hardest after 12 with the sun shining strongest around then.
GOOD LUCK!!! hope you don't get skunked and make me jealous that i couldn't be fishing as well instead =).
 
Great report chibi, well done. Very nice pike and carp. I got to go there soon, probably next week tuesday.

By the way, about eating fish from there,you said it is not healthy to eat fish from there. Most fish I catch I release anyways, But I had some bass from TO Island last year.......................................................................................................................................................
....and.......................I am still alive........... :D :) :)
 
UPDATE

well we headed over yesterday. used the same equipment, went around the same time, left around the same time... however we got skunked. the pike were smart yesterday. frozenfire had many leads... but no takers. he said one even came up to his lure, opened its mouth, and swam away last minute.

we spoke to two other fishers who said the same thing was happening with them although they were able to catch on to a bass.

we saw one guy catch one pike however. it was quite hefty as well.

in terms of the weather, it was a lot sunnier but also windy. it was overcast for awhile but not for long.

we also passed by the police boats twice. they didn't stop to ask us for licenses but watched us.
 
I find urban pike are really hard to figure out on weather patterns. Usually Pike prefer rainy overcast days but with Toronto Pike they bite when they feel like it. Weather doesn't seem to play a factor. Anyone else find this?
 
Nice pike`n I am loving this Island...Like I have said before, this is the first year I have fished it, and I am lovin it!!! again I am going tommorrow!
 
halleb said:
Great report chibi, well done. Very nice pike and carp. I got to go there soon, probably next week tuesday.

By the way, about eating fish from there,you said it is not healthy to eat fish from there. Most fish I catch I release anyways, But I had some bass from TO Island last year.......................................................................................................................................................
....and.......................I am still alive........... :D :D :D

You can eat em...but the more you ingest the more heavey metals you take in, sooo if you wanna remain healthy don`t eat em like they are going outta style, but 1 a month or so would probabaly not do anything too ya....but small, not too big...the older they are, the more mercury and lead in em...and whatever else is floating around out there chemical wise!
 
Back
Top