SUNNY-SIDE UP PLZZZZ...

Ontario Fishing Forums

Help Support Ontario Fishing Forums:

Status
Not open for further replies.
JMatt1983 said:
wrong on so many levels


this is ONLY A GUIDE. you are spreading false information that the fish are inedible and are therefore part of the problem, do you follow the canada food guide recommendations 100%? didn't think so. it does not matter whether or not a GUIDE says its healthy to consume 1 fish per month, the other 4 are still 100% edible

and on further note, I will challenge you to call the MNR to confirm that my information is correct
Click to expand...
exactly just because you shouldnt have more than 1 dosent mean the rest are inedible, they can be eaten by someone else
 
for those of you who think lake ontario salmon are edible, did you ever question as to why your head is growing out of your ass?
 
TRINIBOY said:
CC one question though was intentions to fish with the roe or was it for consumption? Makes a difference, not to say he was right because its totally wrong to kill so many fish just for roe. At the same time you cannot classify all ro
Click to expand...
TRINIBOY said:
CC one question though was intentions to fish with the roe or was it for consumption? Makes a difference, not to say he was right because its totally wrong to kill so many fish just for roe. At the same time you cannot classify all roe users in the same catagory.
Click to expand...
Sorry about the double quote. Trini I think you hit the nail on the head. This roe was for food most likely. Whose gunna fish 50 pounds of roe. Who would buy 50 pounds of over heated crappy roe off kijiji? If you wanna argue the ethics or roe that's fine, but to incite it with a (disguting) picture of food not bait is silly. I don't think we need to.argue about whether or not what buddy did was wrong …
 
steelhead101 said:
for those of you who think lake ontario salmon are edible, did you ever question as to why your head is growing out of your ass?
Click to expand...

your definition of edible is not the same as the provincial governments, get over it. if you want to break provincial laws, thats your own buiness, and i will gladly call mnr on you if i ever see you doing that. please do not spread these practices to others by giving out false information.


if you are not going to eat it, release it, or give it to someone that will eat it. do not ever let a caught fish spoil or rot on the shore, whether you like it or not, it is illegal
 
JMatt1983 said:
your definition of edible is not the same as the provincial governments, get over it. if you want to break provincial laws, thats your own buiness, and i will gladly call mnr on you if i ever see you doing that. please do not spread these practices to others by giving out false information
Click to expand...
dont even cure my own eggs, just dont think its right for you guys posting pictures of some one who isnt doing anything wrong
 
leakywaders said:
Sorry about the double quote. Trini I think you hit the nail on the head. This roe was for food most likely. Whose gunna fish 50 pounds of roe. Who would buy 50 pounds of over heated crappy roe off kijiji? If you wanna argue the ethics or roe that's fine, but to incite it with a (disguting) picture of food not bait is silly. I don't think we need to.argue about whether or not what buddy did was wrong …
Click to expand...

No idea what you're on about Leaky...sorry
 
salmotrutta said:
To clarify:

You don't need a license to sell roe.

Yes it's illegal to sell roe from fish that have been caught. There is a legal way to sell roe and it requires no license..only requires that the eggs be sourced from a legal (aquaculture) source.

If your roe vendor has you questioning their source, ask them where they purchase their roe. There aren't as many aquaculture sources in Ontario as you would think.

They have machines that separate eggs that will hatch from eggs that won't. The eggs that won't hatch, are sold in bulk to roe vendors. Various curing methods are used to bring back colour and desired firmness to the eggs.

If someone is selling roe on Kijiji, they aren't necessarily breaking any laws. But it wouldn't be far fetched to think that some of these 5 hen per outing guys are indeed illegally selling their harvest.
Click to expand...

I think if you ask Mike of Fishheads he will tell you otherwise....
 
leakywaders said:
Sorry about the double quote. Trini I think you hit the nail on the head. This roe was for food most likely. Whose gunna fish 50 pounds of roe. Who would buy 50 pounds of over heated crappy roe off kijiji? If you wanna argue the ethics or roe that's fine, but to incite it with a (disguting) picture of food not bait is silly. I don't think we need to.argue about whether or not what buddy did was wrong …
Click to expand...
steelhead101 said:
dont even cure my own eggs, just dont think its right for you guys posting pictures of some one who isnt doing anything wrong
Click to expand...

having the roe in his possession is not illegal, its the method in which the roe was obtained, ie, gutting the fish and leaving it to rot
 
leakywaders said:
by the demeanor of your posts looks like you've been having a good feed lately…
Click to expand...
i know you are but what am i comment.... c mon.
 
ChaseChrome said:
No idea what you're on about Leaky...sorry
Click to expand...
Chase, I don't think a ban on roe would affect this guy at all. He would still continue to do this every year for some snacks. If these guys who do this crap were selling roe (pretty much impossible to use up fishing) the market would be flooded and 12 bags wouldn't cost a Finn


Steel101 it was more of an im rubber and you're glue comment
 
ChaseChrome said:
I think if you ask Mike of Fishheads he will tell you otherwise....
Click to expand...

CC I've been a roe vendor for about a year now, I've supplied other suppliers, sold directly to consumers, and shops.
 
hahaha caviar--40 lbs of it in case the queen comes to his trailer for lunch hahahahahahahah fantastic shite right there
 
IT IS ILLEGAL TO BUY OR SELL THE ROE OF SPORT CAUGHT FISH
Sport fishing is an important recreational activity for many Ontarians and the Ministry of Natural Resources encourages fishers to make full use of all sport caught fish.
However, an Ontario Sport Fishing Licence is not a licence to sell any part of your catch; it is illegal to buy or sell the roe of sport caught fish.
People who are involved in the illegal sale of fish roe: - harvest fish for the eggs before the fish have an opportunity to spawn, reducing local
population renewal rates; - waste the flesh of adult fish harvested for their roe alone; - deplete local fish stocks during spawning periods when fish are particularly vulnerable; - remove fish and eggs from rivers and lakes; even eggs which do not hatch play a
critical link in the ecosystem; and - increase the chance of spreading fish diseases if the roe comes from disease effected
waters.
Buying or selling of sport caught fish and roe is prohibited under Ontario’s
Fish and Wildlife Conservation Act, 1997.
The maximum penalty for illegal sale or purchase of fish roe is a fine up to $100,000, two years’ imprisonment, or a combination of both.
This legislation protects Ontario’s fish populations by prohibiting sport fishers from harvesting fish for commercial gain.
If you have any information about unlawful sale of fish roe, or any other natural resources violation, call the Ministry of Natural Resources TIPS line at 1-877-TIPS-MNR (1-877-847-7667).
You can also call Crime Stoppers anonymously at 1-800-222-TIPS (8477).


:lol: :lol:
 
CC you'd best RE-READ my post before COMPLETELY making an @$$ of yourself and seriously pi$$ing me off (too late.)

I know you have a decent grasp of the English language, now please prove to me that you can read.
 
I read very well thank you--you've said nothing in your post that says anything at all...
If you are legally licensed to sell roe, then just say so...
 
1. Anyone in Ontario can buy roe from an aquaculture source ( ie. Fish Farm) and re-sell it.

2. There is NO SUCH THING as a license to sell roe.

CC - you fail in basic reading comprehension.
 
These sunny side up eggs have gone bad. Chase you wanna shut her down?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

C
Pearls Before Swine
2
Replies
36
Views
3K
Slickrick
Slickrick

Latest posts

Back
Top