Hey Edwin... After being on an inflatable, I think I can offer some advice
The $200 ones I would probably stay away from. Unless they have multiple separated compartments (so if one leaks, you'll still stay afloat!) and wooden baseboards.
Also the material makes a difference too.
My buddy has an inflatable (which we were on last year at Scugog... where I caught my ridiculous largemouth!). It is super thick, compact, and generally feels pretty safe.
Pumping time (buy a pump besides the boat?)
- pumping time is fairly quick with the included pump or i guess you can go out and buy it. Just a couple minutes and it's done. I'm not exaggerating.
Safety? (Assuming that we will only go out on calm days)
- it is safe.. like you said, assuming you go out on calm days only. The sides are high and generally the whole thing is wide and stable. I would say it's just as safe as a canoe if not more so (less tippy than canoe due to width). In terms of it leaking air due to hooks... I would say that if you were throwing huge muskie lures then, okay...there may be a risk... but smaller sized hooks should pose little risk.
Will the entire setup fit inside a sedan trunk?
- definitely! that's the only reason many people get them, because you don't have to put them on top of a car or store them in garage or backyard...they will and can easily be stuffed into the trunk or put into the basement somewhere when not in use. the one my friend had came in a big duffel type bag... it's just the wooden baseboards that may take up a little more space. not enough to complain about though.
Is there a need to add a motor to one of these things?
- i am going to say DEFINITELY. be it a small gas or a electric trolling motor. when we went out to scugog, we didn't bring a motor and the wind blew us around like we were a leaf on the water. there is very little drag with an inflatable so any current/wind will push you around. we had to paddle till our arms fell off just to fight the wind (10-15km/h) when going back to the launch spot. We also forgot to bring the anchor...which would've helped while we fished.
btw...did pretty well with walleyes yesterday
you got pm'd