My 99% percent guess as well!
It really was a
TRICK QUESTION.
Both picks are the
same fish.
I caught this one the other week while out night fishing for chrome.
It swalled the hook (Roe bag) very deep and I was forced to Keep it.
Originally, I was a bit "Worried" that it was an
ATLANTIC cause it did look different than the typical bows I was catching.
Needless, no matter what it may have been, I did have to keep it.
I posted the Pic on another site asking what they thought and did get
varied answers.
Goes to show that, sometimes it really can be hard to identify.
(The spots on the tail) are supposed to be the real teller.
- There were no clips or tags
As for weight, bait, location ... those really were secondary, I was just playin around.
- about 4lbs
- Roe bags
- Local Trib
As a point of interest, when I caught the fish ... my camera's batteries had died (At least for flash at night) and I didnt have a chance to take until I got home. Amazing how the same fish can look totally different. (Angle, Flash)
The same night I caught this one, I managed about 1/2 dozen others - all 100% bow (4 lb range as well - 100% Catch & Release).
* later in season, bigger ones seem to move in at this location
ps: Was using BARBLESS HOOKS
(Sometimes when they swallow, just cant do anything more, other than not fish and that sure isnt going to happen)
Did batter it up and tasted great!