See if you can guess

[alwayscatching]

The only show I like to watch is Dave Mercer. Otherwise I youtube KVD for some of his stuff. Dave is just entertaining. The guys from Fish TV used to be good with me, then I realized they call every fish a hog averaged out at 1-2 lbs lol.

 

[buck]

.

 

[sunny14]

you know there are very many variations of a hybrid, I still think there is some hybrid in there, it does have the faint bars on it

Buck: I'm inclined to agree with you. No Typical Spotting as for a Pike. BUT! The Jury's Still Out! So I went into My "Fish Biology & Species" Section in "My Documents."

Even The Baby one looks like it.

So here are Four for Yu'alls Consideration.

Rick

 

[steelhead101]

definitely a pike, you will find similar color variations in lake simcoe as well.

 

[fishermandan420]

Def not a tiger. I've caught a couple and that's not what they look like. Pike with cool markings

 

[buck]

.

 

[Rain-Bow]

Tiger muskie aren't able to reproduce.

 

[buck]

Tiger muskie aren't able to reproduce.

.

 

[BASSMASTER19]

Buck: I'm inclined to agree with you. No Typical Spotting as for a Pike. BUT! The Jury's Still Out! So I went into My "Fish Biology & Species" Section in "My Documents."

Even The Baby one looks like it.

So here are Four for Yu'alls Consideration.

Rick

it dosent really help that both of the fish look almost identical except for their markings

 

[BASSMASTER19]

Well then.....thats the end of my theory lol

yep same for me

 

[sunny14]

it dosent really help that both of the fish look almost identical except for their markings

Sorry. Don't quite Understand your Comment. Isn't it the Markings that make them look "Similar"?

I didn't put the Line through your Comment....LOL... I don't know why but every time I go to Post something it's Automatically Turned on? (Fourth from the Left) I can turn it off but can't remove from a Quoted Post. Also this Freakin IE 10 Browser Spell Checks all of the Quotes, including Punctuation!! I have to go through them all and keep Hitting "Ignore".

In any event here's a little more "Biological Info" on the Tiger Muskie". Including Reproduction.

 

[Kit]

Well that sums it up.

 

[sunny14]

Kit: Preston Huh. I'm "Somewhat Older": than you are and I used to play in Leaside Lions Drum & Bugle Corp.

Every time we went to a Competition we had to go up against "Preston Scout House". We didn't stand a chance!! Those guys were Incredible! Including their Outfits, Turned up Aussie Hats, Short Shorts, Knee Socks Etc Etc Etc.

Their Show was Flawless! Man!! They were the best there was!!

(Just a Tad of Topic. I guess) :razz: :razz:

 

[buck]

I hear what you're saying leaky, and I'm not saying that its a full-blown Tiger but what if a tiger bread witha pike and that offspring bread with a pikeand lets say that that happened a few times the fish becomes more and more pike but you see a little bit of the tiger still in there. I think this could happen in areas like Simcoe where there are a lot of pike and only a few musky......I could be wrong, just thinking out loud

In any event here's a little more "Biological Info" on the Tiger Muskie". Including Reproduction.

.

Thanks for the info FishHawk​

 

[Porkpie]

Shame to see that Aaron Shirley hooked up with a convicted poacher.

 

[W_boughner]

I say it's a pike with cool markings

 

[sunny14]

So a female tiger and a male pike can reproduce, I will stick to my theory

Thanks for the info FishHawk​

You're Certainly Welcome Buck! Your Theory from your Post on Sept 18 makes Good Sense to me. It's also one of the reasons I Posted what I did.

I always Insist (to myself, as weird as that sounds) that I should back up any Info that I Post, there an then or at least be prepared to back it up if needed.

Nothing wrong with Personal Opinions as long as that's all they are. An Apparent "Statement Of Fact" is NOT a Personal Opinion or at least it shouldn't be.

It's something that other Members "Learn From" and they TRUST that it is FACTUAL. If it's NOT that creates a Problem of Unknown Proportions.

That's enough. :razz:

 

[Rain-Bow]

Here's the link to the blog where the image was originally posted http://blog.canadian-sportfishing.com/?p=12074

 

[sunny14]

Here's the link to the blog where the image was originally posted http://blog.canadian-sportfishing.com/?p=12074

Well! I guess that's it then! Run your Mouse over the Pic and it says "PIKE"!

Worst part is gettin rid of the Crappy Little Mouse after you do it! I hate those Filthy Things!!!! :razz: :razz:

 

[behnoosh]

Musky/Pike? How to Tell the Difference