Help me choose a CP

Ontario Fishing Forums

Help Support Ontario Fishing Forums:

Catfish said:
Is BO still open? I know that they are closing, just not when.

I probably won't be ordering one online, more likely at sail, caledonia bait and tckle, bill's bait and tackle, grimsby bait and tackle or bronte outdoors if they're still open.
Click to expand...

Yes BO is still open in Mississauga (It was up for sale a month ago) The reason I said go & compare as he had all these reels in the shop including the Aventa & the islander. See how they spin, how heavy they are, how much & how they feel on a rod & that way you will see what you are getting for your money & what one you are more comfortable with.

I saw an older fellow using an Islander on a 13' float rod last September & as he was casting he fumbled and tossed the rod in the river accidentally...I dont fancy doing that with a $500 reel LOL
 
RonnieTO said:
Yes BO is still open in Mississauga (It was up for sale a month ago) The reason I said go & compare as he had all these reels in the shop including the Aventa & the islander. See how they spin, how heavy they are, how much & how they feel on a rod & that way you will see what you are getting for your money & what one you are more comfortable with.

I saw an older fellow using an Islander on a 13' float rod last September & as he was casting he fumbled and tossed the rod in the river accidentally...I dont fancy doing that with a $500 reel LOL
Click to expand...
Maybe he was spear fishing...
 
The reel is not the reason he fumbled...you can fumble with any reel...

Just keep at it when you get into the CP...it can be tricky at first....
 
Catfish said:
I certainly like the looks of the amundson steelheader and no one has said anything bad about it yet.
Click to expand...

I thought the Amundsen and Streamside both felt kinda tinny and weak...

As was mentioned earlier, go to a shop and play with a few.

You can't really explain the quality difference, you have to feel it. High end reels are just solid and tight...
 
Catfish said:
Well that was what i was thinking :oops:. How about a small salmon? :lol:
Click to expand...


like pink and chum? cause chinook are average 15lbs, really big steelheads are 15lbs. once you get the drag system down, you can land anything, mind you, the rating on your rod, is the rating for your leader. so lets say 4-10 is your rating, heaviest leader you can use is 10lb, so if you go over that to fight the salmon and try to horse them out by holding the spool. you might snap your rod in half. but fighting a chinook at 15lb on any leader takes a good 15 minutes, not one of those things your fingers will get used to at all. cause you won't have auto reflexes where your fingers are, how much pressure to put, trust me, plastic/metal spinning at super human speed, don't go well with delicate human skin lol specially chinooks that are known to take very long super sonic runs worth 40 yards of spool in matters of seconds. but if you can pick and choose your salmon size, and can land 2-10 pound fish first, it may not be as bad.
 
Catfish said:
Well i have been talked up higher in the price im gonna put toward the pin.
Here's the amundson steelheader

http://www.fishheadscanada.net/steelheader-centerpin-by-amundson/

It looks virtually the same as the islander, just with amundson stickers.


I could be talked up to this raven

http://www.fishheadscanada.net/products/RAVEN-VECTRA-SST%252d2-CENTERPIN-REEL.html
Click to expand...


I was thinking the SST3, $299, and it is lighter than kingpin r2. it is eight something ounces, which is really light. i have handled one in a store before.
 
coldhands said:
If you're in no rush ask around or take a poll here. I'm fairly new to centerpinning, but I always believe you get what you pay for. I try to buy Made in Canada if possible. I was surprised when I was shopping one in the fall at the difference between low and high end reels.I've bought cars for less. As a beginner I figured I would get something in the middle, that hopefully has a good resell value if I wasn't happy with it. I googled online and checked ratings also. I love my Islander but it's the only one I've used so it's hard for me to compare. Nothing fancy, no drag just my palm which is what I wanted fairly light does what it's supposed to I guess. Hope that helps. check out http://www.centerpinangling.com/
Click to expand...

unfortunately he has never even handled a cp to see if he even loves it enough to spend lot of money on it. CP reels are kind of one dimensional reels, not really good for anything else but streams and rivers. they use them in England but their idea of trophy fish is 2 pound course fish. his budget was 150, i think few of us convinced him to bring it up. i still think he should strongly look into second hand. islander is a great company, just 100% out of his budget range. maybe if he is lucky he can get islander steelheader for 150-200 bucks, and buy the abec 7 bearings eventually for around 90 dollars, and then he has a mid high class reel. CPA is where i might buy my new reel also, but catfish seems to not want to buy anything online.
i have or have had forum on which reel i should buy at my budget of 500-600, and oh trust me. at that range they all become roughly the same.
 
Well i think i've narrowed it down to:
Okuma aventa
Okuma raw
Amundson steelheader

Does anyone know if the raw is any better than the aventa?
 
RonnieTO said:
Yes BO is still open in Mississauga (It was up for sale a month ago) The reason I said go & compare as he had all these reels in the shop including the Aventa & the islander. See how they spin, how heavy they are, how much & how they feel on a rod & that way you will see what you are getting for your money & what one you are more comfortable with.

I saw an older fellow using an Islander on a 13' float rod last September & as he was casting he fumbled and tossed the rod in the river accidentally...I dont fancy doing that with a $500 reel LOL
Click to expand...
Ouch... i'm sure his bank account said "ouch" when he did that :lol:
 
Klik said:
like pink and chum? cause chinook are average 15lbs, really big steelheads are 15lbs. once you get the drag system down, you can land anything, mind you, the rating on your rod, is the rating for your leader. so lets say 4-10 is your rating, heaviest leader you can use is 10lb, so if you go over that to fight the salmon and try to horse them out by holding the spool. you might snap your rod in half. but fighting a chinook at 15lb on any leader takes a good 15 minutes, not one of those things your fingers will get used to at all. cause you won't have auto reflexes where your fingers are, how much pressure to put, trust me, plastic/metal spinning at super human speed, don't go well with delicate human skin lol specially chinooks that are known to take very long super sonic runs worth 40 yards of spool in matters of seconds. but if you can pick and choose your salmon size, and can land 2-10 pound fish first, it may not be as bad.
Click to expand...
The creek i was planning on using it in for chinook is more like 15 feet wide MAX, so the salmon wouldn't even have 40 yards to run.
 
Klik said:
I was thinking the SST3, $299, and it is lighter than kingpin r2. it is eight something ounces, which is really light. i have handled one in a store before.
Click to expand...
The sst3 is out of my price range. Maybe if i win a lottery, but then i'd probably go with an islander.
 
Catfish said:
The sst3 is out of my price range. Maybe if i win a lottery, but then i'd probably go with an islander.
Click to expand...


stt 3 is 300 bucks, lowest end islander is 350+. i did mention find a second handed islander, you can ways upgrade the bearing throughout the years and it will become their top end reel. you can also get a second handed sst3. :) a 5 year old 500 dollar reel is still better tan a brand new 150 dollar reel imo.

you have 9 month, unless you are starting to save up now :)
 
Catfish said:
Has anyone used an okuma sheffield?
Click to expand...

If I knew where you were, when you plan to hit the water, and what your timeline is for a purchase...I'd be happy to put the Amundson (loaded with 200 yrds. of fresh Seaguar Senshi) in your hands to try out for a day....
 
Hey guys, ive been looking at some reels on kijiji.

JW Young- http://hamilton.kijiji.ca/c-buy-and-sell-sporting-goods-exercise-fishing-camping-outdoors-Centre-Pin-float-reel-W0QQAdIdZ443200731

Okuma sheffield- http://hamilton.kijiji.ca/c-buy-and-sell-sporting-goods-exercise-fishing-camping-outdoors-OKUMA-SHEFFIELD-S-1002-FLOAT-REELS-W0QQAdIdZ425347348

Cyprinus- http://hamilton.kijiji.ca/c-buy-and-sell-sporting-goods-exercise-fishing-camping-outdoors-cyprinus-float-reel-W0QQAdIdZ440445990

If anyone has seen or used anyone of those let me know what they're like.
 

Similar threads

Ibstacle
Centerpin Reels For Sale
Replies
1
Views
4K
iJay
iJay
rich_ace_G
Help with steelhead setup...
Replies
13
Views
2K
ChaseChrome
C
rayray519
Float setup/gear help
Replies
9
Views
8K
Shawarma
Shawarma
Neto21
center pin set up help
2
Replies
20
Views
2K
Neto21
Neto21
D
Help with my next purchase
Replies
3
Views
516
Dewy
D

Latest posts

Back
Top