Toronto Islands, first piking experience

Ontario Fishing Forums

Help Support Ontario Fishing Forums:

frozenfire

Moderator
Joined
Sep 19, 2006
Messages
1,869
After the crappie opener on the kawarthas, I've been going often with some pretty good results. After a while, it got kind of repetitive with the slabs, so I decided to try something different. Have never targetted pike before and have never landed one myself, so I decided to give it a try.

Yesterday (May 8th) we made our way down to the islands early morning to beat the morning rush hour. We wanted to catch the 6:30 ferry to Ward Island, but unfortunately, the stupid machine at the dock is really screwy and didn't take any of our cash... we will from now on remember to bring change. Ended up missing the first ferry out and ended up getting the next one.

Awesome day with nice sunshine and weather.
image.php


We started walking along the shoreline casting in all directions with little luck. Soon however, my girlfriend gets a big hit, and it quickly slices through the powerpro like nothing, taking the #4 black fury. Perhaps I should be using some kind of leader to save my lures, any insight on this?
We keep walking and I end up retrieving my xrap to see something following it. I thought that this would be my first pike ever, but it continued to just watch the lure and bolted for deep water after it got too close to the shore. That was soooo cool. Watching the fish stalk the lure. It had some serious heavy scarring around the head though, I'm assuming from the aggressive mating behaviour. I call my gf, my buddy and his gf over and they continue to cast where I saw this fish.

Soon enough, my buddy lands this little one, his first pike.
image.php


5 minutes after that, my gf lands her first pike and the biggest fish she's ever caught. She was so happy ;).
image.php

image.php


At this point, I'm getting pretty confident that I won't get skunked. We keep walking around the shoreline being adventurous, and my buddy hooks into another one, but it shakes the lure out and swims away. We continue to walk around the islands and there is no other fish to be seen for a couple hours. I was starting to feel that I'd be skunked.
As we're fishing, we pass by two other anglers who said that they've been getting lots of follows but no takers.

Then to my surprise, as I was retrieving my lure, a pike shoots up from a patch of weeds and takes it! YES! My first pike. Man, it felt good to see the fish on and to watch it curving it's body in the water.
image.php


We continue to walk with the sun beating down on us and we reach this stretch that produced nicely for me.

First one
image.php


Second one
image.php


Third one. Biggest of the day! was 28.5 inches long and about 5 lbs.
image.php


4th and last fish before we called it a day.
image.php


All in all, I landed 5 pike, gf landed 1 and my buddy got 2 and lost 1 (He also caught a huge OOS largemouth... one of the fatest i've ever seen). I'd say that's pretty good for a first time out targetting a new species.

Another shot of CN tower on our way home.
image.php


Okay, after this trip, I have some questions.
I'm using 35lb powerpro on a shimano stradic 2500 on 6'6" shimano compre combo. This sufficient? I'm loving the reel though. I'm not currently using a leader, and wondering if I should. I noticed that in the morning, the fish weren't that aggressive, and only usually had one hook in the corner of their mouths. Later on in the day, the fish really turned on would totally engulf and swallow xrap 10's.

I noticed that these fish bleed... A LOT, and quite easily as well. Why is this? Whenever they took it in deep, we had to improvise and use branches as jaw spreaders as I forgot to look into them at BPS or Le Barons. Hahaha. One of the pike bled VERY bad, the ending treble on the xrap caught onto the 3rd gill branch beneath the operculum and it took a while to get it out. It didn't seem to hook into anything, but i'm guessing during the fight, the hook caught onto the gill filaments or the rakers on the other side of the gill arch. They all swam off with a splash, but am unsure of their survival. Is there any way I can avoid the damage done? Don't want to see these cool fish die. Perhaps using barbless will save a lot more fish? My gf got so disgusted with all the blood and didn't want to catch any more cause of this haha.

Had so much fun that I'm going to head back down tomorrow. Hope the second time is as good as the first. I'm looking to break 30 inches :D.

***Edit by Openfire to add map showing where frozenfire caught fish***

torislands.jpg
 
wow, way to go on the pikes, you are making me regret moving to ottawa...

I guess barbles hooks would help reduce the bleeding, it wouldnt tear as much if it got into the gills. i think there is also some harness thing to hold the pikes when they get on shore so they dont trash around as much.

i like the colouring of pikes, it reminds me of a baby deer. Is it me or do pikes smell especially fishy?

i hope its still good during vic weekend....
 
Nice report :D I was actually going to head down (in the afternoon) yesterday !! But now I'm regreting it lol ;) I thought it would be too hot by the time I got there. I instead checked out Lake Wilcox w/ one of my beginner fishing buddies, teaching him how-to fish etc. He didn't get any fish, but he got a few bites tho. So what was the key to catching the fish yesterday ? very long-pauses ? I've yet to catch my first pike, which is why I'm asking :D I still also have to stop by Lebarons to get a few husky jerks, lost 2 of them in weeds last year. Thinking of going by the islands on Friday possibly, I wonder what the colder weather will do to their appetite.
 
Oh Bloody Awesome!!

What lures/color did you use ?
That is what I want to know.

Thanks!
 
thanks guys!

lure of choice were assorted xraps of all sizes and colours. they all caught fish haha.

fish were slowwwww in the morning, but were crazy aggressive when it got hot.
 
Congrats Frozenfire! Thanks for the report!

Those Xraps are deadly.

I wish I could see the all the pics but 5 of them didn't show up :D Maybe you could upload them to our gallery instead of using photobucket.

Scent might actually turn a lot of those followers into strikes. ;)

About the leader... I would have thought that 35 lb test would have been sufficient. I know that some people use steel leaders, but that adversely affects the presentation. You could use a barrel swivel with a more abrasion resistant line as your leader instead...

I would also think that going barbless would help with minimizing the damage to the fish... Maybe replace the treble with a barbless siwash... You'll hook slightly less, but land a higher %... they penetrate quite nicely.

Hey Frozenfire, I'm gonna post a google map for the islands... maybe you can circle the spot/s you we fishing and I'll add that to your report.

Man I have to get down to the islands soon!

Awesome job!!! :D
 
OK Frozenfire, if you can circle the spots on this map where you hit your fish, I'll add it into your report.

torislands.JPG


Thanks again man!
 
i showd on the pic where i caught some fish. we had lots of follows and also saw lots of fish that weren't willing to bite.
the pic i uploaded to the gallery, but don't kow how to attach it. openfire, can you do it for me?

I think the general consensus when comparing my results with that of mikey's is that around the central bridge is the place with most success. i also see the more people fishign there as well... must mean that fish are holding there.[/img]
 
That is great.

I sure am gonna go visit the island again and work the other areas a lot more.



But also, I want to try a lot more of topwater this time.
 
Thanks openfire...

man, getting a huge hit from a pike on topwater would be sooooo cool. I'm guessing that early morning would be best for topwater? These fish seem to be quite shy.
 
frozenfire,,,

So how did you work the x-rap ?

How I did was, short snap , snap, snap , pause...

I personally like the crown color because i cause see it in the water better.
 
Great reports guys !! frozenfire, I was VERY tempted to use my pop-r's the islands :D I was just worried someone might see me thinking I was fishing for bass lol, I shoulda did it anyways ;)

question: were you guys doing short pauses or very long pauses ?
 
i tried to mix up my retrieves, when I saw that the pike were following, I ouwld pause for a longer than usual...

I tend to mostly do a slow retrieve, letting the lure work itself. When you feel something heavy on, fish on! haha.
 
I also tried the islands on saturday and got nothing...

the pikes are still there though, i saw a bunch crusing around, but they didnt seem too interested in eating for some reason.

I also saw how tough bass r... one little bass was guarding its rock nest when this pike 4 times bigger than it came along... the bass lunged at it and the pike ran away into deeper water... i thought i was gonna see a fight.

there were actually a lot of bass in the islands, would be nice to visit it when they r in season.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top